Commentary Tahir Aslam Gora
The London bombings have shocked the world and once again raised the question 'Why?'. But people who hurry to blame fundamentalists and poverty are missing the point: Islam itself. A commentary by Tahir Aslam Gora
Tahir Aslam Gora says that US-American/British foreign policy cannot be seen as the primary and legitimate reasons behind Islamic fundamentalism Today there is a lot of talk about the root causes of Islamic terrorism and how to deal with them.
So what are these root causes then? UK-US foreign policy? The West's lust for oil? Illiteracy and poverty in the Muslim world? The hijacking of Islam by a few extremists?
These, amongst others, are the reasons most left-wing intellectuals and self-declared liberal Muslim thinkers, from British journalist Robert Fisk to Pakistani author Tariq Ali, are providing for the attacks on London and Islamic terrorism in general.
Muslims vs. Muslims
But let's be frank. While we can't deny the double standards of US foreign policy or America's quest for hegemony, when have Muslim states not shown the same double standards regarding international affairs? Haven't Muslim nations tried to dominate their own neighbours, even when those neighbours are part of their Muslim brotherhood?
Pakistan's quest for hegemony in Afghanistan, Syria's hold on Lebanon, Iraq's attacks on Iran and Kuwait; these are just a few prominent examples. And our famous progressive Muslim scholars barely mention the barbarianism of Muslim Iraq, Iran and Turkey towards Muslim Kurds.
So let's look at the real root cause of Islamic terrorism: Islam today. World leaders, in order to maintain religious harmony, claim that Islam is a religion of peace. But in fact there are several fundamental flaws in the teachings of Islam: gender inequality, intolerance of non-Muslims and limited personal freedoms (including freedom of expression and the creative arts).
It is true that Islamic terrorism is staged by only a small percentage of extremist Muslims; however, it is also true that this terrorism is not strongly condemned by the majority of other Muslims.
The need for change
Progressive Muslim scholars claim that Islam has been 'hijacked' and that ordinary Muslims don't support terrorism. If this statement is true, then why is Osama Bin Laden a hero in most Islamic countries? Walk on the streets of Pakistan, Sudan, Bangladesh, Indonesia, Somalia and many other Muslim countries and you will see the respect and love shown for Bin Laden and other leaders like him.
This respect is not a result of illiteracy and poverty but of the way in which Islam is taught. This is why thousands of Muslim doctors, professors and other highly qualified professionals do not condemn Islamic terrorism.
The world's media and leaders need to focus on truly liberal Muslims who have the courage to demand real change to remedy the basic flaws of Islam. Those self-declared progressive Muslims who try to justify Islam as a religion of peace and tolerance are just making the situation more confused.
There are many real liberal Muslim scholars who have been proposing changes to Islam for years, but their voices are constantly and deliberately being ignored by the media. If these voices start getting heard, perhaps they will change the traditional Muslim mind for the better.
Tahir Aslam Gora
© Café Babel 2005
Tahir Aslam Gorais a Pakistani writer living in exile in Toronto (Canada). He is the author of several books including "Why Terrorists Are Muslims?" and the founder of the New Islam movement.
Printversion
Islam Needs to Evolve
The London bombings have shocked the world and once again raised the question 'Why?'. But people who hurry to blame fundamentalists and poverty are missing the point: Islam itself. A commentary by Tahir Aslam Gora
Tahir Aslam Gora says that US-American/British foreign policy cannot be seen as the primary and legitimate reasons behind Islamic fundamentalism Today there is a lot of talk about the root causes of Islamic terrorism and how to deal with them.
So what are these root causes then? UK-US foreign policy? The West's lust for oil? Illiteracy and poverty in the Muslim world? The hijacking of Islam by a few extremists?
These, amongst others, are the reasons most left-wing intellectuals and self-declared liberal Muslim thinkers, from British journalist Robert Fisk to Pakistani author Tariq Ali, are providing for the attacks on London and Islamic terrorism in general.
Muslims vs. Muslims
But let's be frank. While we can't deny the double standards of US foreign policy or America's quest for hegemony, when have Muslim states not shown the same double standards regarding international affairs? Haven't Muslim nations tried to dominate their own neighbours, even when those neighbours are part of their Muslim brotherhood?
Pakistan's quest for hegemony in Afghanistan, Syria's hold on Lebanon, Iraq's attacks on Iran and Kuwait; these are just a few prominent examples. And our famous progressive Muslim scholars barely mention the barbarianism of Muslim Iraq, Iran and Turkey towards Muslim Kurds.
So let's look at the real root cause of Islamic terrorism: Islam today. World leaders, in order to maintain religious harmony, claim that Islam is a religion of peace. But in fact there are several fundamental flaws in the teachings of Islam: gender inequality, intolerance of non-Muslims and limited personal freedoms (including freedom of expression and the creative arts).
It is true that Islamic terrorism is staged by only a small percentage of extremist Muslims; however, it is also true that this terrorism is not strongly condemned by the majority of other Muslims.
The need for change
Progressive Muslim scholars claim that Islam has been 'hijacked' and that ordinary Muslims don't support terrorism. If this statement is true, then why is Osama Bin Laden a hero in most Islamic countries? Walk on the streets of Pakistan, Sudan, Bangladesh, Indonesia, Somalia and many other Muslim countries and you will see the respect and love shown for Bin Laden and other leaders like him.
This respect is not a result of illiteracy and poverty but of the way in which Islam is taught. This is why thousands of Muslim doctors, professors and other highly qualified professionals do not condemn Islamic terrorism.
The world's media and leaders need to focus on truly liberal Muslims who have the courage to demand real change to remedy the basic flaws of Islam. Those self-declared progressive Muslims who try to justify Islam as a religion of peace and tolerance are just making the situation more confused.
There are many real liberal Muslim scholars who have been proposing changes to Islam for years, but their voices are constantly and deliberately being ignored by the media. If these voices start getting heard, perhaps they will change the traditional Muslim mind for the better.
Tahir Aslam Gora
© Café Babel 2005
Tahir Aslam Gorais a Pakistani writer living in exile in Toronto (Canada). He is the author of several books including "Why Terrorists Are Muslims?" and the founder of the New Islam movement.
Qantara.de
Fareena Alam
Five Principles for Islam's Future
Islam can move beyond its association with oppression and violence by being true to itself and its past, says Fareena Alam. In her article, she argues for a promotion of spirituality and morality, and for the separation of state and church
Commentary Amr Hamzawy
The West Must Now Speak with Islamists
Egyptian political scientist Amr Hamzawy argues that critical dialogue with Islamists would allow influence to be exerted on the most dynamic political groups in the Arab world, whose members have partly become religious democrats
www
Fareena Alam
Five Principles for Islam's Future
Islam can move beyond its association with oppression and violence by being true to itself and its past, says Fareena Alam. In her article, she argues for a promotion of spirituality and morality, and for the separation of state and church
Commentary Amr Hamzawy
The West Must Now Speak with Islamists
Egyptian political scientist Amr Hamzawy argues that critical dialogue with Islamists would allow influence to be exerted on the most dynamic political groups in the Arab world, whose members have partly become religious democrats
www
- Tahir Aslam Gora's "New Islam" website
- Café Babel Online - Multilingual European current affairs magazine
Printversion
The scope of the Iranian government's crackdown on dissent since the disputed June 2009 elections is even broader and the abuses more flagrant than previously reported. More on Human Rights Watch...
Renowned Columbia University Iran scholar Hamid Dabashi hosts "The Week in Green: A Window into the Iranian Civil Rights Movement". The weekly program aims to keep audiences plugged in to news and analysis on the pro-reform Green Movement in Iran. More...
The documentary film The Making of Islam: Empire of Faith covers more than a thousand years of history and culture, and a very large part of the world. Watch full PBS documentary on YouTube...
In "Ghost Wars", Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Steve Coll tells the secret history of the CIA's role in Afghanistan, from its covert program against Soviet troops from 1979 to 1989, to the rise of the Taliban, to the secret efforts by CIA officers to capture or kill bin Laden in Afghanistan after 1998. More...
AVAAZ.org is an international civic organisation that promotes political action on issues such as human rights, and religious conflicts. The NGO's "Stop the Clash" video has had nearly 1.5 million views. Click here...
- Literary Dialogues
- Religious Dialogue
- Cultural Dialogue
- Israel, Palestine
- Islamic Feminism
- Reformist Islam
- Islamism
- Europe, Turkey
- Headscarf Debate
- Globalisation
- Musical Worlds
- Iranian Cinema
- Internet
- Travelogues
- Women in the Islamic World
- Democracy and Civil Society
- Migration in Germany
- Art in the Islamic World